Salary site comparison

Levels.fyi vs Payscale: which is more accurate?

For pay at a named company and level, Levels.fyi gives the more precise number, in any role. Each salary is one person's pay, with level, years of experience, city, base pay, equity, bonus, regional pay and the date. The median US software engineer total compensation on Levels.fyi is $209,000 over the last 12 months (November 2026). Payscale returns a report built from a profile you complete.

  • Payscale's salary survey asks for annual base salary on its first screen. Later screens open only after you answer, so we did not check them [5].
  • Payscale says it priced 60 million jobs in 2024 and serves 16,000+ customers [2].
  • Levels.fyi shows the data points behind every number, and medians by level such as $414,000 at Google L5.
  • Submissions are checked in tiers. How the data is checked.

Up to 27 fields per salary on Levels.fyi, vs 6 on the first screen of Payscale's salary survey (checked November 13, 2026). How we count

Updated November 13, 2026. Facts about other sites come from their own public pages, linked under Sources with the date we checked them.

Levels.fyi is the subject of a Harvard Business School case study, and its data is used in NBER working papers w33903 and w33383. The Wall Street Journal, the Financial Times, Bloomberg, Fortune and Wired have cited it (press).

“It was a playbook that I followed step-by-step that helped me get a much higher salary than what was initially offered.”
D.W., Principal Engineer, negotiation coaching client
“This gave me a lot of confidence to stick to my ask and I ended up getting the top of the band offer.”
Anonymous, Data Engineer, negotiation coaching client
“I ended up with a very nice signing bonus as well as additional equity that I would have never thought to ask for if it weren't for Taylor's guidance.”
M.T., Electrical Engineer, negotiation coaching client

Read the published client outcomes

Software engineer pay in the United States: two ways to count it

As of November 12, 2026.

SourceFigureWhat it counts
Levels.fyi, all levels$209,000Median total compensation (base, stock and bonus), last 12 months
Levels.fyi, Google L4$295,985Median total compensation at one company and level
Levels.fyi, Google L5$414,000Median total compensation at one company and level
IndeedAbout $136,500 per yearAverage salary on Indeed's salaries page; the page does not say how it is built

Two things drive the gap: levels and stock. A title-wide figure blends levels, and a figure without stock misses much of senior pay. See software engineer pay by company and level.

Use Levels.fyi for accurate pay in any role: offers, level benchmarking and negotiation.

Use Payscale for a salary report built from a profile you complete, or for employer job pricing.

Levels.fyi records up to 27 fields per salary, including level, years in level, equity vesting, bonus types and 13th month pay.

Every field Levels.fyi collects, and how we count

Levels.fyi vs Payscale at a glance

Levels.fyiPayscale
Data sourceIndividual submissions from the people earning the pay; never from employersSalary profiles completed by individuals; its About page describes its collection as always on [1][2]
What you seeIndividual data points and per-level distributionsA salary report for your profile [1]
How it is checkedIn tiers; offer letters, W-2s and pay stubs get the most weightIts About page says its data is validated [2]
Fields per salaryUp to 27 (how we count)6 on the first screen of its salary survey [5]
LevelThe company's own ladder, mapped across companiesThe survey's first screen asks job title and years of experience, with no level field [5]
Pay parts askedBase, 13th and 14th month, holiday allowance, RSUs with the vesting schedule, options, token grants, target and average bonus, sign-on in years 1 and 2, relocation, profit sharing, commission and OTEAnnual (or hourly) base salary on the first screen. Later screens open only after answering, so we did not check them [5]
Offer or current payEvery submission dated, with new or current pay marked; new data every dayThe first screen asks whether the salary is for a current job or a job offer [5]
Scale1M+ salaries shared; 5,000+ companies60M jobs priced in 2024; 16,000+ customers and 20% of the US workforce [2]
AccessFree for individualsComplete a salary profile to get a report [1]
Employer productsCompensation benchmarking, APIAscent, JobNav, JobNav Recruiter, Paycycle [2]
Best forAccurate pay for any offer, level benchmarking, negotiationA report built from your profile; employer job pricing

Numbers in brackets point to Payscale's own pages under Sources, with the date we checked each one.

Two data models

Levels.fyi shows the data points. You can see individual salaries at a company, level and city, each dated and split into base, equity, bonus and regional pay, and the distribution they form. Levels.fyi does not collect pay data from employers. Every field Levels.fyi collects.

Payscale returns a report. You complete a salary profile, and Payscale generates a salary report for it [1]. The first screen of its survey asks for your job title, years of experience, location and annual base salary, and whether the pay is for a current job or an offer [5]. Its About page says its data is validated and its collection is always on [2].

Where the numbers diverge, and why

  • Levels. A figure for a job title blends levels. At Google, the L5 median on Levels.fyi is $414,000 and the L4 median is $295,985.
  • Pay parts. At many companies, stock, bonus, commission or a 13th month salary is a big part of pay. A figure that leaves them out understates total compensation.
  • Employer mix. A figure across the whole economy blends many employers. A company-level figure shows what your employer pays.

Indeed and Salary.com in one minute

Indeed shows average pay by job title. In November 2026 its salaries page listed Software Engineer at about $136,500 per year, with no note on how the average is built [3]. Use it for a quick sense of a title across employers.

Salary.com sells compensation data to employers. It says it combines employer-reported survey data with job-posting data, that employers submit their own pay data to its surveys, and that it covers 1.4 million leveled job titles across 225 industries [4]. It is built for HR teams pricing jobs.

Which to use

Holding an offer at a named company and level, in any role? Use Levels.fyi, and compare the same level, city and time window.

Want a report built from a profile you fill in? That is what Payscale offers. Setting pay for a company? Payscale, Salary.com and Levels.fyi all sell employer products.

What Payscale does better

  • A salary report built from a profile you complete [1].

Frequently asked questions

Is Levels.fyi better than Payscale?

For accurate pay, yes. Levels.fyi records each salary in more detail: level, years of experience, city, date, base, equity, bonus and regional pay such as a 13th month salary. That lets each number be compared like for like, in any role and industry. It checks submissions in tiers, and those backed by an offer letter, W-2 or pay stub get the most weight.

Why are Payscale and Levels.fyi numbers so different?

Different data and different math. Payscale returns a report for a profile you complete. Levels.fyi shows company-level submissions that include stock and bonus. A figure that blends levels or leaves out stock will sit below a level-specific total compensation figure.

Does Levels.fyi include stock compensation?

Yes. Levels.fyi records stock grants with their vesting schedules and annualises them into total compensation, and shows a first-year total that adds the sign-on bonus.

Do I need to pay to use Levels.fyi?

No. Salary and leveling data, the tools, the job board and the community are free. Find your role.

Is Indeed or Salary.com better than Levels.fyi for salary data?

For an offer at a named company and level, use Levels.fyi. Indeed shows average pay by job title, and its salaries page does not say how the average is built. Salary.com sells employer-reported market data to HR teams.

Find your role

Other comparisons

Sources

  • [1] Payscale, For Individuals: “Complete Your Salary Profile”, “Generate your salary report”. payscale.com/for-individuals, checked November 12, 2026.
  • [2] Payscale, About: “60M jobs priced through Payscale in 2024”; “16,000+ customers and 20% of the US workforce”; says its collection is always on and its data validated; products Ascent, JobNav, JobNav Recruiter, Paycycle. payscale.com/about, checked November 12, 2026.
  • [3] Indeed, Salaries: Software Engineer “$136,593 per year” when checked; no methodology note on the page. indeed.com/career/salaries, checked November 12, 2026.
  • [4] Salary.com, By the Numbers: “combines employer-reported survey data with real-time job posting intelligence”; “Employers submit their own pay data to Salary.com surveys”; 1.4 million leveled job titles; 225 industries. salary.com, checked November 12, 2026.
  • [5] Payscale, salary survey, first screen: “Which option best describes your situation?” (Current Job or Job Offer), Job Title, Years of Experience, Location, Country, annual or hourly, Type of Currency, Annual Base Salary, Salary Reported For, then “Next: Skills”. payscale.com/survey, checked November 13, 2026.
  • Levels.fyi figures: Levels.fyi data for US software engineers, last 12 months, November 12, 2026. Verification method: levels.fyi/about.

Glassdoor, Blind, Payscale, Indeed and Salary.com are trademarks of their respective owners. Levels.fyi is not affiliated with or endorsed by them.